Card Condition Guide
Understanding card condition is essential for both buyers and sellers. Use this guide to accurately assess and list your cards.
Why Condition Matters
Accurate condition grading builds trust with buyers and helps your cards sell faster. Overgrading leads to returns and negative reviews. When in doubt, grade conservatively — buyers appreciate honesty.
Raw Card Conditions
These grades apply to ungraded (raw) cards. Inspect your card under good lighting on both front and back.
Factory sealed, unopened, brand new. The card or product has never been removed from its original packaging. This applies to sealed booster packs, sealed tins, ETBs, and other factory-sealed products.
What to look for:
- • Original shrink wrap or factory seal intact
- • No tears, punctures, or openings in packaging
- • Packaging in good condition (no crushing or water damage)
A very clean card with minimal wear. This is not a perfect card and it is not a graded 10 — but it's close. Near Mint cards look great in a binder or display and are the standard for most collectors.
What to look for:
- • Very slight whitening on one or two edges (barely visible)
- • No scratches visible to the naked eye on the front
- • Corners are sharp or have extremely minor softness
- • Clean surface with no print lines, dents, or indentations
- • Centering may be slightly off but not drastically
Minor wear is visible upon inspection. The card still presents well and is perfectly acceptable for most collectors. Think of this as a card that's been handled a few times or sat in a binder.
What to look for:
- • Light whitening visible on edges
- • Minor surface scratches (visible at an angle under light)
- • Slight corner wear or minor dings
- • No creases or bends
- • Overall still a clean-looking card
Noticeable wear that's visible at arm's length. The card is structurally sound but has clearly been played with or stored without sleeves. Good for binder collectors who care more about the card than perfection.
What to look for:
- • Obvious whitening on multiple edges
- • Visible scratches on the surface
- • Minor creasing or light bends
- • Corner wear clearly noticeable
- • Some scuffing on the foil/holo area
Significant wear is clearly visible. The card has seen a lot of use. Suitable for players who need the card for gameplay or collectors filling gaps in a set at a lower price point.
What to look for:
- • Heavy whitening across most edges
- • Noticeable creases or bends
- • Significant surface scratches
- • Rounded or heavily dinged corners
- • Card still intact and recognizable
Major damage that significantly affects the card's appearance or structure. These cards are typically only valuable if the card itself is rare or sought-after despite the condition.
What to look for:
- • Tears, rips, or missing pieces
- • Heavy creases that break the surface
- • Water damage, staining, or discoloration
- • Writing, stickers, or residue on the card
- • Severe structural damage
Graded Cards
Graded cards have been professionally evaluated, encapsulated in a tamper-proof case, and assigned a numeric grade. Grading removes subjectivity and provides a trusted standard.
Grading Companies
The most recognized grading company for trading cards. PSA grades on a 1-10 scale. PSA 10 (Gem Mint) is the highest grade and commands the highest premiums. PSA is the industry standard for Pokémon and sports cards.
Known for sub-grades across four categories: centering, corners, edges, and surface. A BGS 10 (Pristine) or Black Label 10 (all four sub-grades are 10) is extremely rare and valuable. Popular for modern cards.
A newer entrant to card grading (known originally for comics). CGC also provides sub-grades and has gained popularity for competitive pricing and faster turnaround times.
One of the oldest grading companies with a strong reputation for vintage cards. Their tuxedo-style black holders are distinctive. SGC grades on a 1-10 scale and is especially popular for vintage sports cards.
Understanding the Grading Scale
| Grade | Label | Description |
|---|---|---|
| 10 | Gem Mint / Pristine | Virtually flawless. Perfect centering, sharp corners, clean edges, and pristine surface. |
| 9 | Mint | One very minor flaw. Extremely clean card with only a tiny imperfection under magnification. |
| 8 | Near Mint-Mint | Very clean with a few minor flaws. Slight whitening or a minor print imperfection. |
| 7 | Near Mint | Small flaws visible to the naked eye. Light whitening, minor wax staining, or slight off-centering. |
| 6 | Excellent-Near Mint | Noticeable handling wear. More whitening and possibly a light crease or two. |
| 5 | Excellent | Moderate wear all around. Visible flaws but card still looks decent overall. |
| 4 | Very Good-Excellent | Well-worn with obvious flaws including possible creases and rounded corners. |
| 3 | Very Good | Heavy wear. Multiple creases, significant whitening, but no major structural damage. |
| 2 | Good | Severely worn. Major creasing, staining, or other damage. Card still intact. |
| 1 | Poor | The lowest grade. Heavy damage but the card can still be identified. May have tears or missing pieces. |
Should You Get Your Cards Graded?
Grading adds value to high-demand cards in excellent condition. A PSA 10 Charizard is worth significantly more than a raw Near Mint copy. However, grading costs money and takes time — it's usually only worth it for cards valued at $50+ in raw condition. Use our Card Scanner to check market prices before deciding.
Ready to List Your Cards?
Now that you know how to grade your cards, list them with confidence. Our AI scanner helps fill in the details automatically.